MAD FOR MATTE PLAID - NOTD TAKE 2

I know I know, I went on and on about how shiny these nails were and then I go and make them matte. But I couldn't resist. I think the matte made these nails look more fall like and made them look very velvety too. What do you all think, matte or shiny??

Also thank you VIXXAN from THE GLAM SHACK for naming my polish for me! As you see I now have it labeled and ready to go.